Old Tax Regime vs New Tax Regime: Which Should I Choose While Filing ITR?
For a salaried person with no business income, the choice between the old and new regime can be made again every year, including at the time of filing. Your employer's TDS was based on a declaration, but it does not bind you.
Quick Answer
Salaried taxpayers can pick whichever regime gives lower tax when they file the ITR, and the difference is settled as a refund or additional tax. Taxpayers with business or professional income must give Form 10-IEA by the due date to opt for the old regime and have limited ability to return to the new regime later.
Two kinds of taxpayers
| Taxpayer | Choice |
|---|---|
| Salary, pension, interest, rent, capital gains only | Choose each year in the ITR. The new regime is the default. |
| Business or professional income | Opt out of new regime by Form 10-IEA by the ITR due date. Once you return to the new regime you generally cannot opt out again while you have business income. |
Break-even: how many deductions make the old regime win
These figures are for a resident, AY 2026-27, standard deduction of ₹75,000 (new) and ₹50,000 (old), and they exclude surcharge. Deductions mean 80C, 80D, HRA, home-loan interest and similar.
| Annual salary | Tax in new regime (with cess) | Deductions needed (besides standard deduction) for the old regime to match |
|---|---|---|
| ₹10 lakh | Nil | About ₹4.5 lakh |
| ₹12.75 lakh | Nil | About ₹7.25 lakh |
| ₹15 lakh | ₹97,500 | About ₹5.4 lakh |
| ₹20 lakh | ₹1,92,400 | About ₹7.1 lakh |
| ₹30 lakh | ₹4,75,800 | About ₹8 lakh |
What this means
At ₹12.75 lakh and below the new regime has no tax at all because of the rebate, so the old regime can only match it with very high deductions. Above ₹15 lakh, if your genuine deductions (HRA, interest on a home loan, 80C, 80D, NPS) are above the numbers shown, the old regime pays off. Compute with your own numbers, since HRA and home-loan interest vary a lot.
How to settle the difference at filing
- Check Form 16 and the regime your employer used.
- In the ITR utility choose the regime in the 'filing' section. For the old regime enter all deductions with proofs.
- Compare the tax computed with TDS. If TDS was higher you get a refund; if lower, pay self-assessment tax before filing.
- E-verify the return.
Common traps
- Claiming the old-regime HRA after employer used the new regime without proof of rent.
- Forgetting Form 10-IEA when you have business income.
- Choosing the old regime without checking that you actually paid the premium or EMI.
- Assuming the employer's choice is final.
Practical Checklist
- Download Form 16 and AIS.
- Compute tax in both regimes.
- Check proofs for each deduction.
- Select the regime in the ITR.
- Pay balance or claim refund and e-verify.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I change regime every year?
Yes, if you have no business income.
Can my employer force a regime?
They deduct TDS as per your declaration, but you can still choose at filing.
Is the 87A rebate available in both regimes?
Yes, with different limits: ₹60,000 up to ₹12 lakh taxable income in the new regime, and ₹12,500 up to ₹5 lakh in the old regime.
Related Questions
- Can I Switch Between Old and New Tax Regimes Every Year?
- Which Deductions Are Allowed in the New Tax Regime?
- How Do I Choose the Tax Regime While Filing My ITR?


